Manchester United lost their unbeaten record after a valiant performance from Huddersfield.
The Terriers led 2-0 at the break after goals from Aaron Mooy and Laurent Depoitre with United losing Phil Jones to injury.
Marcus Rashford got one back for United but it was a particularly disappointing display.
Our man David Anderson was at the John Smith’s Stadium and was not impressed with some United players.
Here are his full player ratings.
Lossl 6 – Saved a Herrera header and stood firm in frantic finale.
Smith 7 – Booked. Caught Martial with a tasty tackle to set the tone for Huddersfield.
Jorgensen 7 – Played his part as Huddersfield snuffed out United’s attack.
Schindler 8 – Booked. Huddersfield’s defensive linchpin kept a close eye on Lukaku.
Lowe 6 – Was solid on the left up against the tricky Lingard.
Hogg 7 – Anchored Huddersfield’s midfield to give Mooy licence to attack.
Kachunga 7 – Had a header saved before he was forced off in the first half.
Williams 6 – Booked. Put in a real shirt in the midfield engine room for the Terriers.
Mooy 8 MOTM – Booked. Started and finished the move for Huddersfield’s opener.
Ince 8 – Had a hand in the first and was a real nuisance on he left.
Depoitre 7 – Capitalised on Lindelof’s mistake to make it 2-0 to the Terriers.
Van La Parra (Kachunga 39mins) 6,
Mounie (Depoitre 69mins) 6,
Malone (Ince 90+2mins).
De Gea 6 – Saved from Ince, but was beaten twice.
Valencia 6 – Raided forward well down the right and was a threat.
Smalling 6 – Started well, but suffered when Jones went off injured.
Jones 7 – Was rock solid before he was hurt making a fine tackle.
Young 6 – Booked. Pushed forward from left-back and had a shot wide.
Matic 6 – Had a shot deflected wide just before half-time.
Herrera 6 – Struggled to make an impact before having a header saved.
Lingard 6 – Was dangerous for United with his direct running.
Mata 4 – Lost the ball in midfield to Mooy for the Terriers’ opening goal.
Martial 4 – Booked. Was rattled and might have walked for a retaliatory kick on Smith.
Lindelof (Jones 23) 3,
Mkhitaryan (Mata 45mins) 6,
Rashford (Martial 45mins) 7.